I think this is the best photo because it follows all of the criteria. Like shes not ready and its unexpected which makes the moment more real. I also like how she fits the frame nothing is distracting in the picture and all you focus on is her.
I think this is the worst photo because she is not in the frame. There are alot of other things that are distracting. I think that her emotion and everything is good but I think they need to turn the camera on her more.